14 Comments
User's avatar
Mrs Miller's avatar

this is powerful stuff. and thank you for introducing me to the charnel ground. how did i live all these years and not hear of that? "what's next" is an apt reminder to stay curious. life happens for us and not to us after all. really the perfect essay to help assuage my own temporary groundlessness. thank you Leah! ❤️

Expand full comment
Leah Rose's avatar

Thank YOU! It's so gratifying to know this felt helpful. And I get your surprise about the charnel ground—I felt the same way when I read of it in Pema Chödrön's book, Living Beautifully with Uncertainty and Change. It's one of my favorites of hers, along with Start Where You Are. Both provided me some deeply challenging and life-altering perspectives.

Expand full comment
Mrs Miller's avatar

Ooh I don’t know which one to read first! 🥰

Expand full comment
Leah Rose's avatar

Personally I’d recommend Start Where You Are as a great place to start.😊 The title provides the key: learning how to BE in the moment you’re in.🪷

Expand full comment
Leah Rose's avatar

(Ugh...that blocked-out emoji at the end there is a lotus.)

Expand full comment
Mrs Miller's avatar

😂

Expand full comment
Mrs Miller's avatar

Thank you. I like direction. 👍🏼

Expand full comment
Chris Nathan's avatar

What a haunting metaphor - the charnel ground - for the spiritual place where chaos reigns and peace seems gone forever. I won't forget that. You have vividly represented it.

I am a little more than a third of the way through a book that I want to offer to you as a possible way to add an unexpected dimension to your assertion "that life is truly a process, peace is always a practice." With the exception of one book I read many years ago nothing I've come across has so deeply illuminated the place from which experience flows and so altered for me both what I see and the way I see it. Calling that "what I think" is too narrow. It's more like "how I think" - except that even the verb "think" is too narrow. You address that place in the final paragraphs of this essay, and your writing makes evident the power of it. You're writing an essay, so you're constrained by not just the linear-ish form of the essay but also the object-orientation-ishness of words and sentences. Clearly it's not merely "remembering" that all is well, even though... it is also remembering that all is well.

I want to be a little less abstract here, and more personal. I've spent many years trying to find a way to think about what I do every day that will relieve the massive anxiety I live with that I'll wake up one day and discover that I irrevocably squandered the opportunity that was my life. The prospect of dying from covid, or anything else for that matter, doesn't trouble me nearly as much as the fear that I just didn't do enough, that I took all the opportunity I had and just... frittered it away. That's my charnel ground.

Anyway, reading this book ("The Master and His Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World" by Iain McGilchrist; Yale University Press, 2009) has done more than anything I've come across in decades to reconstitute the system in which I experience (my) life and that whole question about what's enough. The transition through to the other side of fear and anxiety that you describe in your essay resonates with the reaction I'm having to this book's representation of human experience's essentially dual construction. I have, until now, always thought of myself as living in a mostly unitary "house of being." I now find myself reconsidering that entire model.

Expand full comment
Leah Rose's avatar

Thank you for sharing these deeply honest reflections, Chris.

I, too, felt the haunting power of that charnel ground imagery when I first read about its Buddhist framing in Pema Chödrön's book, "Living Beautifully With Uncertainty and Change." It has been very useful to me in the intervening years when I am caught up with worry and dread. Focusing on it really does help me to breathe into the moment, re-center myself in equanimity and curiosity.

I've heard of Iain McGilchrist though I haven't read his work; your recommendation will change that. I'm intrigued by your description of its impact on your understanding and worldview. My personal demons are not the same as yours, but I suspect it will have an expanding effect on the way I see myself and the world around me. Thank you for the recommendation, and the effort to contextualize it. Best wishes on your journey.

Expand full comment
Frederick R Prete's avatar

A very thoughtful essay, thank you.

Expand full comment
Leah Rose's avatar

Thank you. And thanks for recommending. :)

Expand full comment
Frederick R Prete's avatar

My pleasure.

Expand full comment
PSweeney's avatar

This is beautiful Leah:

…. life is truly a process, peace is always a practice, and I will be okay.

We all will be okay.

Expand full comment
Leah Rose's avatar

Thank you. I'm glad to hear it resonated.

Expand full comment